Cheating In a Technology Rich Environment
Combating Plagiarism with Technology
Henry E. Schaffer
Professor Emeritus of Genetics and Biomathematics
Coordinator of Special IT Projects & Faculty Collaboration/OIT
Interim Director Emeritus, LTS/DELTA
NC State University
Does it happen?
On-line
"Paper Mills" or "Essay Mills" (An old list - but things haven't
improved!)
YES!!!!
Essay mills are still popular in 2019 How
Students May Be Cheating Their Way Through College
Buying
essays experiment
The
Shadow Scholar "The man who writes your students' papers tells his
story" - affluent students aren't limited to paper mills. :-) Might this
automated writing service put
him out of a job?
An
interview with The Shadow Scholar Also see his Wikipedia page
More companies in this business! The
New Cheating Economy Plagiarism and much more! (premium access
Chronicle article) Don't stop at buying the paper (see Shadow Scholar
above and below,) buy the whole course!
And faculty are also cheating! "Fake scientific papers are alarmingly common" and journals are concerned.
Overviews: Excellent Resource Pages (mostly from Libraries)
Video
on Plagiarism (may load slowly)
Fair use A very important
limitation to US copyright protection
Plagiarism
on Campus "Resources to Help Detect, Prevent and Avoid Classroom
Plagiarism for Teachers and Students"
"PLAGIARISM:
AVOID THE CONSEQUENCES" a nice short description of various
types of plagiarism and a guide to proper citation of sources.
Avoiding Plagiarism
Resources for Web Plagiarism:
Prevention and Detection (no longer available at uncc.edu, this link
is to archive.org)
College Guide to Preventing Plagiarism From Maryville University.
A
discussion of methods of Detecting Plagiarism
PLAGIARISM
RESOURCES (FOR STUDENTS & TEACHERS IN 2019) Discussion, examples and
a quiz.
A
Guide to Copyrights, Trademarks and Patents in Print and Beyond with
many links. (P.S. Thanks, Erin.)
Plagiarism
A Guide and a Tutorial.
"Preventing Cheating & Plagiarism as an Online Student" Briefly reviews
many forms of cheating and then focuses on plagiarism. Gives many examples
and links to resources.
Why is referencing important? A nice brief overview of avoiding
(unintentional) plagiarism by using proper citations of references.
Non-text Plagiarism: Computer software
Does it happen?
Academic Dishonesty in a High-Tech Environment (also includes text
cheating) - An ACM SIGSE Bulletin - should be available through your university Library
Moss (Measure
Of Software Similarity) a detection tool.
SNITCH
(Spotting and Neutralizing Internet Theft by CHeaters) a detection
tool.
Teaching
Academic Honesty in CS50 An interesting and provocative article on
the steps they have taken and the results. It includes a link to their
Open Source software (compare50) for cross-comparison of coding
assignment submissions.
Using Technology
Note: plagiarism checkers (and other tech tools) vary greatly in capability. You may want to try out a number of them with your own examples before choosing one.
Technology and Methods
- A free
challenge method
Theory and
discussion
Another version
with a better printout for the instructor
Yet Another
version with printout which can make it easier to evaluate
- Turnitin.com a well known
commercial service for higher ed (see some more immediately below)
Plagiarism.org an educational
resource developed by Turnitin.com
preventing
plagiarism
iThenticate
the commercial (non-edu) version of turnitin
Similarity Check
"powered by iThenticate is an initiative started by CrossRef to help
its members actively engage in efforts to prevent scholarly and
professional plagiarism." It's a project of a group of scholarly publishers.
turnitin for admissions was
a version for use by Admissions Offices used for
online admissions
- "A Web-Enabled Plagiarism Detection Tool" by Colin J. Neill and Ganesh
Shanmuganthan in the Sept-Oct 2004 issue of the IEEE IT Professional
pp 19-23.
- An interesting different approach - Chegg's (free)
Citation
Generator which, by making it easier for the writer to cite sources,
can help avoid accidental plagiarism. It also reminds the writer of the
need to cite sources
Two style guides from Chegg which include citing are
Chegg offers additional free services such as their
Learn which provides helpful
materials in a number of (mostly STEM) disciplines. (Chegg has been a
somewhat contraversial company as its "help" services are sometimes
used by students to cheat.)
- Copyleaks plagiarism checker
(has other services available on that page)
- SafeAssign is a plagiarism
prevention service with educational content from BlackboardTM
- CROT provides a "FREE plagiarism
detection service for your Moodle server"
- WCopyfind
"an open source windows-based program that explores a collection of
documents, looking for matching language.
- Plagiarism Checker X
takes a document you have and checks sentences via "all leading search
engines"
- Free Plagiarism Checker
"Multilingual, professional, online"
-
Top 10 Free Plagiarism Detection Tools For Teachers
- "A cloud-based tool for assessing
originality" VeriCite (now a part of Turnitin)
- A free plagiarism detection tool
- Viper Plagiarism Scanner
has a free version
- Unicheck was UnPlag.
- PlagScan
- ITS
free plagiarism checker
- A free
plagiarism checker by EDUBIRDIE
- A plagiarism checker
- BibMe Plagiarism and
Grammar Checker. A good discussion of plagiarism. They also have a limited
free version and a more comprehensive for-pay version of the checker.
Note: in many situations, proper citation is considered important and
often the format of the citation is considered important. BibMe has two
style guides to assist in proper citation:
-
Citation Machine Emphasis on proper citation and suggestions on
improving writing - with a free account. (It's been pointed out that
there are so many banner ads as to make it difficult to use.) "Unintentional
plagiarism" detection is included in the paid account.
- Citation generation -
Currently supports the APA, MLA and Chicago citation formats. A
startup planning to include other text improvement features in their
ad-free service.
- TypeCite A citation generator.
It's supposed to be free for student use.
- Zotero "is a free, easy-to-use
tool to help you collect, organize, cite, and share research." There
is a charge for storage which exceeds their 300MB free limit.
- Another area where plagiarism is of concern
is in blogging. Some detection tools are mentioned, especially Copyscape.
- Since paying attention to citation can help in avoiding plagiarism,
here's another helper - for Chicago
style
-
Chegg Writing Plagiarism Checker It's selling a for-pay service, but
it has lots of helpful information about what is plagiarism and how to
avoid it. Included is a 5 minute video which may help inform students.
- compilatio plagiarism detection
- Plagiarism Checker
- Do your own search - put quotes in a search engine
e.g., Go to Google or
Go to DuckDuckGo
and paste this
into the search box: "many facets to understanding plagiarism"
You'll
find this web page near the top of the search results. (Plus some more
of my web pages on this topic.)
- While any web search engine can be used to search the web,
there is a search service which emphasizes "scholarly literature,
including peer-reviewed papers, theses, books, preprints, abstracts and
technical reports from all broad areas of research." and can be used
"to find articles from a wide variety of academic publishers,
professional societies, preprint repositories and universities, ..."
This is Google Scholar, and can
be used as an additional source. Microsoft has some academic books
searchable via its Bing search engine.
Defeating Plagiarism Detection!
There are incentives to commit plagiarism which is why we see it
occurring. This led to the development of the many tools to detect
plagiarism. If plagiarism detection works to detect plagiarism, then
it becomes more difficult to get away with plagiarism. (Of course!) So
there is an incentive to develop methods to evade detection.
Unsurprisingly this has already happened, although the methods/tools
aren't advertised as having this purpose, but rather as being methods of
rephrasing or paraphrasing text to innocent purposes. E.g.
Paraphrasing Tool
Article
Rewriter Tool maybe this one isn't too worrisome?
Paraphrasing Tool -
Paraphrase your article with a sentence rephraser. This says it uses
AI to paraphrase in order to avoid plagiarism.
Paraphrasing tool uses AI.
Rewriter Tools
Turnitin
discussion "word spinners"
Text Spinners and the Problem of Paraphrase Plagiarism
Uses and Discussion
Understanding & Preventing Plagiarism - Strategies & Resources for
Students and Teacher A comprehensive review by Matt Ashare.
Actions Do Speak Louder than Words: Deterring Plagiarism with the
Use of Plagiarism-Detection Software by Bear F. Braumoeller and Brian J.
Gaines. PS: Political Science and Politics, 34:835-9 December 2001
(available through JSTOR)
Term
Paper Mills, Anti-Plagiarism Tools, and Academic Integrity
by M. Groark, D. Oblinger and M. Choa
Are
Algorithmically-Generated Term Papers the Next Big Challenge to
Academic Integrity? But is it plagiarism?
Technology
and Plagiarism in the University: Brief Report of a Trial in Detecting
Cheating by Johnson,D., Patton,R., Bimber,B., Almeroth,K.,
and Michaels,G. 2004 - "reports the results of a trial of
automated detection of term-paper plagiarism in a large, introductory
undergraduate class." It covers deterrance and student reactions.
Teachers Adjust Lesson Plans as Web Fuels Plagiarism
Is trying to detect plagiarism unethical? or illegal?
Pima Community College creates "traffic school" for plagiarists -
looking for the URL
Anti-Plagiarism Strategies for Research Papers
How Dumb Do They Think We Are? by Jonathan Malesic. A teacher's take on
student plagiarism.
"Guilty Until Proven Innocent: The Well-Known Secret about
Turnitin.com" is a rather hostile anti-Turnitin discussion. I can't find
it any longer, but there is a
description of this topic available.
A
comparison of 7 anti-plagiarism software tools by Liz Johnson
How
first year composition students write research papers.
A
short discussion of using plagiarism checkers in online learning
"How to Prevent Plagiarism and Cheating in Grad School" A guide for grad students and also colleges, with lots of links to resources.
P.S. My
short discussion in the context of Computer and Information Literacy
or Fluency, and
"How to
get away with plagiarism" My discussion of ethics and plagiarism.
More resources:
- Self-plagiarism is a somewhat complicated area. It can vary from
re-use of a phrase or a sentence, which is usually considered to be
innocuous, to resubmission of an essay or article, unaltered or lightly
changed, which is usually considered to be an ethical violation.
- The
Ultimate Plagiarism Guide: How to Detect and Prevent It
- Evaluating
Online Resources: The Complete Beginner's Guide
-
Copyright Explained For Students: Don't Get Caught Out
-
- Plagiarism Resources
- International
Journal for Educational Integrity "The journal provides a platform
for educators across all sectors to research issues in the
multi-disciplinary field of educational integrity."
- NC State Libraries Tutorial on Plagiarism
-
Avoiding Plagiarism, Self-plagiarism, and Other Questionable Writing
Practices: A Guide to Ethical Writing
- Plagiarism
in the Corporate World - with a $1 million result.
- NC State Univ
Code of Student Conduct Section 8.4 Plagiarism
- -->
Copyright Jungle by Siva Vaidhyanathan. A discussion of legal, business,
ethical and practical aspects. (Columbia Journalism Review Sept/Oct 2006)
(soon to be available again at www.cjr.org)
- Plagiarism and
the Web
- The
Little Book of Plagiarism by Richard A. Posner, a noted jurist and
legal scholar.
- Plagiarism
harms readers and has other faults.
- Faculty
Theft - Are faculty/administrators innocent of plagiarism and other
academic thefts?
-
Saving Time or Betraying Trust? discussion of U. Md. CP's discussion
-
Plagiarism in Chinese higher ed from the Chronicle (subscription required)
- Arguing Against Free-Market Plagiarism Prevention" from Inside Higher Ed
- Plagiarism
and Historical Journals from the American Historical Association. A
news article "Confronting
- and Not Confronting - Plagiarism" covers an AHA panel - from
Inside Higher Ed
- IEEE
Procedures for Publications see Section 8.2.4 for Allegations of
Author Misconduct - which includes plagiarism
- Plagiary "A refereed online
journal ... addressing general and specific issues related to
plagiarism, fabrication, and falsification." It has ceased publication,
but back issues are at the link given.
-
A Plague of Originality by Peter W. Morgan & Glenn H. Reynolds discusses the
dangers of overenthusiastic labeling similarities as "plagiarism".
This is Chapter 5 in their book "The Appearance of Impropriety:
How the Ethics Wars Have Undermined American Government, Business, and
Society. Some background for this is at The Appearance of Propriety
by Peter W. Morgan
- Spy vs spy
This represents the wrong way to work with students.
-
2 Universities' Plagiarism Policies Look a Lot Alike Was one of them
plagiarized? [available to Chronicle subscribers - may be available
through your campus library]
- Student Guide to Understanding and Avoiding Plagiarism in the Classroom
and Online a discussion with links to additional resources
- Let's
Talk About Plagiarism by a composition teacher
- Internet
Resources on Citing: The Trademark of a Good Writer
- "A
Plague of Originality" an interesting essay diverging from some
common views.
- Some more
background on The Shadow Scholar.
And then a
darker look at The Shadow Scholar.
- New Jester Collusion
Detection Reports "the correlation and matches between Adobe PDF
and Microsoft Word documents". (only those two formats). An interesting
tool which might have some use in plagiarism checking. Not free, but
"Pay What You Want", through PayPal, starting with $1 AUD.
-
Plagiarism and Paraphrasing An overview with a very good discussion
of the educational purpose of avoiding plagiarism. A number of links are
given and Plagiarism
Information gives a lot of useful information, including citation.
-
"How Do I Use the Copyright Symbol?" A short treatment of the use of
the copyright symbol and how to register a copyright.
- A
Business Guide to Copyrights, Trademarks, and Patents
Brief business-oriented descriptions of these areas with many links.
- A
Guide to Trademarks, Copyrights, and Patents for Websites and Beyond
A general review. H/T Katie!
-
Guide to Prevention of Academic Plagiarism
- How much Plagiarism is committed by administrators and faculty?
- ACM Policy on Plagiarism, Misrepresentation, and Falsification (Association for Computing Machinery)
- [ACM] Ethics and Plagiarism Update
Was http://www.ncsu.edu/it/open_source/chitre.html
or
https://projects.ncsu.edu/it/open_source/chitre.html
now is
https://hescgi.oit.ncsu.edu/chitre.html
Copyright 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013,
2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024
by Henry E. Schaffer Comments and
suggestions are welcome, and should go to hes@ncsu.edu
Last modified 7/9/2024
Disclaimer - Information is provided for your use. No endorsement
is implied.